Assisted Living vs. Care Homes / Board & Care: What’s the Difference?
As loved ones age, their needs often change—sometimes gradually, sometimes unexpectedly. Families may begin to notice challenges with cooking, managing medications, mobility, or even loneliness. When living at home is no longer safe or practical, it becomes necessary to explore long-term care options that provide both support and peace of mind.
Two of the most common choices are assisted living communities and care homes (also known as board and care homes). At first glance, they may seem similar since both provide seniors with housing, daily meals, and assistance with personal care. However, they differ in important ways that can shape your loved one’s experience—such as the size of the facility, the atmosphere, the type of care provided, and the overall lifestyle offered.
Making this decision goes beyond comparing costs. It’s about finding the right balance of independence, safety, and comfort in an environment that best matches your loved one’s personality, health needs, and daily preferences. Understanding the distinctions between assisted living and care homes can help families choose the setting where their loved one will feel most supported, respected, and at home.
Is assisted living the right fit?
Discover the best senior living options for you.
Take our free assessment to find communities tailored to your needs.
Key Takeaways
Assisted living is bigger with more amenities.
Care homes are smaller and more home-like.
Assisted living suits social, active seniors.
Care homes suit quiet, private seniors.
Assisted living usually costs more.
Care homes are often more affordable.
Choose based on needs and comfort.
What is Assisted Living?
Assisted living is one of the most popular senior living options because it strikes a balance between independence and support. It is designed for older adults who are generally healthy and mobile but may need a little extra help with daily tasks. Unlike nursing homes, which focus on medical care, assisted living communities provide a safe, comfortable environment where seniors can enjoy life while still receiving the assistance they need.
These communities are often large, apartment-style complexes that look and feel like senior-friendly resorts or condominiums. They’re built to promote safety, convenience, and social interaction, while still giving residents the privacy of their own space.
Common Features of Assisted Living
1. Size & Layout
-
Communities typically range from 50 to over 200 residents, creating a bustling environment where seniors have many opportunities to meet new people.
-
Residents usually live in private or semi-private apartments, each with its own bathroom, small kitchenette, and living area. This allows seniors to maintain their independence while knowing help is always close by.
-
2. Amenities
-
Assisted living communities often include resort-like amenities such as restaurants, cafés, beauty salons, fitness centers, libraries, movie theaters, activity rooms, and landscaped gardens.
-
Many offer walking paths, patios, and outdoor spaces designed for relaxation and social gatherings.
3. Services Provided
-
Staff members help with activities of daily living (ADLs) such as bathing, grooming, dressing, and medication reminders.
-
Services usually include meals, housekeeping, laundry, and transportation to medical appointments or shopping.
-
Some communities also offer wellness programs, on-site therapy, or visiting healthcare providers.
4. Social Life
-
Assisted living communities place a strong emphasis on keeping residents engaged and active.
-
A full calendar of events may include fitness classes, arts and crafts, cultural outings, educational workshops, religious services, and holiday celebrations.
-
Dining is often done in a shared restaurant-style dining room, giving residents a chance to socialize over meals.
5. Staffing & Care
-
Staff are available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, to ensure residents receive prompt assistance when needed.
-
While assisted living is not designed for residents who need advanced medical care, basic health monitoring is provided. For skilled medical needs, outside providers such as nurses or therapists may visit.
Who Is Assisted Living Best For?
-
Seniors who enjoy social interaction and want to live in a community setting with plenty of opportunities to make friends.
-
Individuals who value independence but also appreciate knowing that support is available when needed.
-
Older adults who thrive on routine and structure, and who would benefit from organized activities, group dining, and access to wellness programs.
-
Seniors who no longer want the responsibilities of homeownership—such as cooking, cleaning, or yardwork—but still want a private living space.
Assisted living is often the perfect middle ground: it’s not as medically intensive as a nursing home, but it provides more support than living alone at home. For many families, it offers peace of mind knowing that their loved one is cared for, while also giving the resident the freedom to live a full, active life.
What Is a Care Home / Board & Care?
Care homes, also known as residential care homes or board and care homes, provide seniors with a more intimate and homelike alternative to larger assisted living communities. These residences are usually located in quiet, residential neighborhoods, and they are often converted houses adapted to safely accommodate older adults who need daily assistance.
Unlike the resort-style feel of many assisted living communities, care homes focus on creating a comfortable, family-like atmosphere where residents can receive personalized care in a smaller setting. For seniors who may find large facilities overwhelming or impersonal, a care home offers the warmth and familiarity of living in a house rather than an institution.
Common Features of Care Homes
1. Size & Layout
-
Care homes typically house between 4 to 10 residents, making them significantly smaller than assisted living facilities.
-
Residents may have private or shared bedrooms, and common spaces usually include a living room, kitchen, and family-style dining area.
-
The smaller size creates a cozy, close-knit environment where residents and staff know each other well.
2. Atmosphere
-
Living in a care home feels much like being in a regular household.
-
Meals are home-cooked and served family-style at a shared dining table, often with the ability to accommodate individual dietary preferences.
-
The pace is generally slower and more relaxed, with fewer distractions than in a large community setting.
3. Services Provided
-
Residents receive assistance with daily living tasks, including bathing, dressing, grooming, toileting, mobility, and medication management.
-
Housekeeping, laundry, and meal preparation are included as part of the care.
-
Depending on the care home, additional services such as transportation, physical therapy, or dementia care may also be available.
4. Social Life
-
Social interaction in care homes is smaller in scale and less structured than in assisted living.
-
Activities may include light exercise, puzzles, music, television, gardening, or small group gatherings.
-
While there may not be a packed activity calendar, residents benefit from meaningful one-on-one engagement with caregivers and fellow residents.
5. Staffing & Care
-
Care homes typically have a lower staff-to-resident ratio, allowing caregivers to provide highly personalized attention.
-
Staff often develop close relationships with residents, learning their preferences, habits, and routines.
-
This makes care homes especially beneficial for seniors who need more supervision or who appreciate a familiar, consistent caregiving team.
Who Are Care Homes Best For?
-
Seniors who prefer a quieter, family-like setting rather than the hustle and bustle of a large community.
-
Individuals who need more one-on-one attention due to mobility issues, chronic conditions, or memory challenges.
-
Older adults who may feel anxious or overwhelmed in large groups and instead thrive in a smaller, more intimate environment.
-
Families who want the reassurance that their loved one is living in a safe, cozy home with attentive caregivers.
Care homes are a wonderful option for seniors who value comfort, familiarity, and individualized care. They may not offer the wide range of amenities and activities found in assisted living, but they provide a sense of closeness and personal attention that many families find comforting.
Assisted Living vs. Care Homes / Board & Care: Key Differences
Size
-
Assisted Living: Large communities, often with 50 to 200+ residents.
-
Care Homes / Board & Care: Small homes, usually with 4 to 10 residents.
Living Space
-
Assisted Living: Private or semi-private apartments with bathrooms, kitchenettes, and living areas.
-
Care Homes / Board & Care: Bedrooms in a house-like setting, either private or shared.
Atmosphere
-
Assisted Living: Social, vibrant, and community-focused, with resort-style amenities.
-
Care Homes / Board & Care: Quiet, cozy, and family-like, offering a more intimate feel.
Activities
-
Assisted Living: Wide range of structured programs such as classes, outings, and events.
-
Care Homes / Board & Care: Fewer activities, but more personalized and flexible.
Staffing
-
Assisted Living: 24/7 staff available, but with a higher resident-to-staff ratio.
-
Care Homes / Board & Care: 24/7 staff with a lower ratio, allowing more individualized attention.
Medical Support
-
Assisted Living: Basic health monitoring; outside providers visit for skilled nursing or therapy.
-
Care Homes / Board & Care: Focused daily assistance; some homes may offer specialized care.
Cost
-
Assisted Living: Typically higher due to larger facilities, amenities, and programming.
-
Care Homes / Board & Care: Generally more affordable, with fewer extras but highly personalized care.
Best For
-
Assisted Living: Independent, social seniors who enjoy group activities and access to amenities.
-
Care Homes / Board & Care: Seniors who prefer a quieter, homelike setting with closer supervision.
Cost Considerations
For most families, cost is one of the biggest deciding factors when comparing assisted living and care homes (board & care). While both options include housing, meals, and personal support, the price can vary significantly based on location, level of care, amenities, and staffing ratios.
Assisted Living Costs
-
Generally more expensive due to larger facilities, resort-style amenities, and structured activity programs.
-
National averages in the U.S.: Around $4,000 to $6,500 per month, though prices can climb much higher in metropolitan areas or luxury-style communities.
-
Additional fees may apply for:
-
Memory care services
-
Help with mobility or incontinence
-
Extensive medication management
-
Transportation or special dining requests
-
-
Some communities offer tiered pricing models, where the base rent covers housing and meals, and extra care is added on as needed.
Care Home / Board & Care Costs
-
Usually more affordable than assisted living because of the smaller setting and fewer large-scale amenities.
-
National averages in the U.S.: Typically $3,000 to $5,500 per month. Costs can be higher in specialized homes that provide Alzheimer’s or dementia care.
-
Fees usually include room, meals, laundry, and personal care (like bathing and medication help), with fewer unexpected add-ons.
-
Because of the small size, care homes sometimes provide better value for seniors who need more one-on-one support without paying resort-level prices.
Factors That Affect Both
-
Location: Costs in urban centers and high-cost-of-living states (like California or New York) are significantly higher than in rural areas.
-
Room Type: Private rooms cost more than shared accommodations, sometimes by $500–$1,500 per month.
-
Level of Care: The more support a senior requires, the higher the monthly rate. This can include help with mobility, advanced dementia care, or specialized medical needs.
-
Pricing Models: Some providers use an all-inclusive model (one set monthly fee), while others charge a la carte fees for additional services.
Always request a detailed cost breakdown before making a decision. Understanding what’s included in the monthly fee—and what might come as an extra charge—can prevent surprises and help you make the best financial choice for your loved one.
How Families Can Decide
Choosing between assisted living and a care home can feel overwhelming, especially when the well-being of a loved one is at stake. The right decision depends not only on practical needs like health and safety, but also on lifestyle preferences, budget, and the type of environment where your loved one will feel most at home. Below are some important considerations to help guide families through this process.
1. Health & Care Needs
The level of care your loved one requires is often the first factor to assess.
-
Assisted Living: Best suited for seniors who are relatively independent but may need assistance with daily tasks like bathing, dressing, or medication management. These communities are ideal for older adults who still want autonomy but need the reassurance of help being close by.
-
Care Homes: A better option for seniors who require closer supervision and more frequent hands-on support. For example, those with mobility challenges, early dementia, or chronic health conditions may thrive in the more intimate, attentive environment of a care home.
Tip: Ask yourself — Can my loved one safely navigate a larger community, or do they need more constant oversight in a smaller setting?
2. Social Preferences
Social engagement plays a major role in overall well-being and can influence which setting is more suitable.
-
Assisted Living: Ideal for seniors who enjoy being part of a larger, vibrant community. With group activities, shared dining, and planned outings, these communities encourage friendships and social connection.
-
Care Homes: A better choice for those who prefer quiet, smaller gatherings or who may feel overwhelmed by crowds. Residents often build closer bonds with caregivers and fellow residents in a family-like atmosphere.
Tip: Consider your loved one’s personality. Are they energized by group activities, or do they prefer a calm, cozy environment?
3. Budget Considerations
Finances are an important part of the decision-making process.
-
Assisted Living: Typically comes with a higher price tag due to its larger staff, amenities, and community offerings. While it provides many perks, not all families may find it financially sustainable long-term.
-
Care Homes: Generally more affordable, though prices can vary based on location, staffing ratios, and level of care provided. Families may find care homes to be a better fit if they need personalized care without the added expense of large-community amenities.
Tip: Ask providers for a detailed breakdown of costs (rent, care services, meals, activities) to avoid hidden fees and unexpected expenses.
4. Atmosphere & Environment Fit
The “feel” of a place can significantly impact your loved one’s happiness.
-
Assisted Living: Offers a more structured, bustling environment with scheduled activities and larger dining areas. This works well for seniors who thrive on routine and enjoy a busy atmosphere.
-
Care Homes: Provide a slower-paced, homelike setting where residents can relax in shared living rooms, enjoy home-cooked meals, and form close-knit bonds. Seniors who find comfort in familiarity and personal attention often do better here.
Tip: Visit both types of communities. Bring your loved one along, if possible, so they can experience the environment firsthand.
5. Family Involvement
The role of family can also influence the decision.
-
Care Homes: Families often develop closer relationships with caregivers due to the small size of the setting. This can foster a sense of trust and partnership in providing care.
-
Assisted Living: While still supportive, the larger size and more formal structure may create a professional distance between families and staff. However, many families appreciate the organized systems, on-site nurses, and structured communication provided.
Tip: Think about how much involvement your family wants to have in the day-to-day care of your loved one.
Every family’s situation is unique, and there is no one-size-fits-all answer. Start by asking:
-
What type of care is truly needed?
-
What environment will make my loved one happiest?
-
What can our family realistically afford?
-
How much do we want to be involved in their care on a daily basis?
Taking the time to weigh these factors — and touring multiple options — can help ensure you choose the best possible setting for your loved one’s comfort, safety, and overall quality of life.
